last modified 9-15-04
PHIL 100: Socrates and Plato
Fall 2004; David O. Brink
Syllabus
Here are the topics and readings for the course, listed in the order
in which we will do them. (We'll have to see if we get to section
9 by the end of the course.) Required readings are drawn from the
required texts and are preceded by '(A)'. Recommended readings are preceded
by '(B)'. Especially recommended readings are preceded by an asterisk.
Bibliographic details for texts can be found on the Select Bibliography.
1. PRESOCRATIC BACKGROUND
-
(B) Adkins, Merit and Responsibility, chs. i-xii; Aeschylus, Agamemnon;
Barnes, Early Greek Philosophy (esp. Heraclitus, Parmenides, and
Democritus); Dover, Greek Popular Morality; Hesiod, Works and
Days and Theogony; Homer, Iliad (esp. i, vi, ix, xvii,
xix, xxiv); Irwin, Plato's Moral Theory, ch. 2 and *"Plato: The
Intellectual Background" in The Cambridge Companion to Plato, ed.
Kraut; Sophocles, Antigone and Oedipus the King.
2. SOCRATES AND PLATO
-
(A) Apology.
-
(B) Crito. *Aristotle, Metaphysics i 6, xiii 4; Cooper, "Notes
on Xenophon's Socrates" in Cooper, Reason and Emotion; *Irwin, Plato's
Ethics, ch. 1 and "Plato: The Intellectual Background" in The Cambridge
Companion to Plato, ed. Kraut; Lacey, "Our Knowledge of Socrates" in
Socrates,
ed. Vlastos; Penner, "Socrates and the Early Dialogues" in The Cambridge
Companion to Plato, ed. Kraut; *Vlastos, "The Paradox of Socrates"
in Socrates, ed. Vlastos, and *Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher,
chs. 1-3.
3. SOCRATIC METHOD AND ETHICS
-
(A) Euthyphro; Laches; Lysis esp. 219d-220b; Euthydemus
esp. 278e-282e.
-
(B) *Charmides. *Irwin, Plato's Ethics, chs. 2-5; *Penner,
"The Unity of Virtue" reprinted in Essays on the Philosophy of Socrates,
ed. Benson, and "Socrates and the Early Dialogues" in The Cambridge
Companion to Plato, ed. Kraut; Santas, "Socrates at Work on Virtue
and Knowledge in Plato's Laches" in Socrates, ed. Vlastos and Socrates;
Vlastos, "What Did Socrates Understand By his 'What is F?' Question?" in
Vlastos, Platonic Studies, *Socrates, Ironist and Moral Philosopher,
chs. 4-8, and *Socratic Studies, chs. 1-3, 5.
4. HEDONISTIC ANSWERS TO SOCRATIC QUESTIONS: THE PROTAGORAS
-
(A) Protagoras.
-
(B) Devereux, "The Unity of the Virtues in Plato's Protagoras and
Laches;
Gosling and Taylor, The Greeks on Pleasure, ch. 3; *Irwin, Plato's
Ethics, ch. 6; McDowell, "Virtue and Reason"; *Penner, "The Unity of
Virtue" reprinted in Essays on the Philosophy of Socrates, ed. Benson;
*Taylor, Plato's Protagoras [notes]; Rickless, "Socrates' Moral
Intellectualism"; *Vlastos, "The Unity of the Virtues in the Protagoras"
in Vlastos, Platonic Studies and "Introduction" to Plato's Protagoras,
ed. Vlastos.
5. DISOBEDIENCE AND DEMOCRACY: THE CRITO
-
(A) Crito.
-
(B) Brickhouse and Smith, Socrates on Trial; *Irwin, "Socratic Inquiry
and Politics" and *"Socrates and Athenian Democracy"; *Kraut, Socrates
and the State; Santas, Socrates, ch. 1; Vlastos, "The Historical
Socrates and Athenian Democracy" in Vlastos, Socratic Studies; Woozley,
"Socrates on Disobeying the Law" in Socrates, ed. Vlastos.
6. THE PARADOX OF INQUIRY AND RECOLLECTION: THE MENO
-
(A) Meno.
-
(B) *Fine, "Inquiry in the Meno" in The Cambridge Companion to Plato,
ed. Kraut; Gallop, Plato's Phaedo [notes]; *Irwin, Plato's Ethics,
ch. 9; Moravcsik, "Learning as Recollection" in Plato I, ed. Vlastos;
White, Plato on Knowledge and Reality, ch. 2.
7. SENSIBLE FLUX, FORMS, AND IMMORTALITY: THE PHAEDO
-
(A) Phaedo; Republic 476e-480a, 523-525, 596a-598d.
-
(B) *Fine, "Separation" and "The One Over Many"; Irwin, Plato's Heracliteanism"
and Plato's Ethics, ch. 10; Vlastos, "Reasons and Causes in the
Phaedo" in Vlastos, Platonic Studies; White, Plato on Knowledge
and Reality, ch. 3 and "Plato's Metaphysical Epistemology" in The
Cambridge Companion to Plato, ed. Kraut.
8. THE REPUBLIC
-
General.
-
(A) Republic, esp. i-vii
-
(B) Annas, An Introduction to Plato's Republic and Platonic Ethics,
Old and New;Cross and Woozley,
Plato's Republic; *Irwin, Plato's
Ethics, chs. 11-18; Reeve,
Philosopher-Kings; White, A Companion
to Plato's Republic.
-
Doubts about Justice.
-
(A) Republic i-ii (through 367e).
-
(B) *Gorgias; *Irwin, Plato's Ethics, chs. 11-12; White,
"The Classification of Goods in Plato's Republic".
-
Moral Psychology and the Virtues.
-
(A) Republic ii-iv.
-
(B) Cooper, "The Psychology of Justice in Plato" and "Plato's Theory of
Human Motivation" in Cooper, Reason and Emotion; *Irwin, Plato's
Ethics, chs. 13-14.
-
The Eudaimonist Defense of Justice.
-
(A) Republic iv, viii-ix.
-
(B) *Gorgias; *Irwin, Plato's Ethics, chs. 15, 17; *Kraut,
"The Defense of Justice in Plato's Republic" in The Cambridge Companion
to Plato, ed. Kraut; *Sachs, "A Fallacy in Plato's Republic" in Plato
II, ed. Vlastos; Vlastos, "Justice and Happiness in the Republic" in
Vlastos, Platonic Studies.
-
Platonic Love.
-
(A) Symposium 210-212; Phaedrus 230-234, 237-257.
-
(B) Brink, "Self-love and Altruism" and "Eudaimonism, Love and Friendship,
and Political Community"; *Irwin, Plato's Ethics, ch. 18; Price,
Love
and Friendship in Plato and Aristotle, chs. 2-3; *Vlastos, "The Individual
as Object of Love in Plato" in Vlastos, Platonic Studies.
-
Metaphysics and Epistemology.
-
(A) Republic v-vii, x.
-
(B) *Phaedo; *Fine, "Knowledge and Belief in Republic v-vii"; *Irwin,
Plato's
Ethics, ch. 16; Vlastos, "Degrees of Reality in Plato" in Vlastos,
Platonic
Studies; White, Plato on Knowledge and Reality, ch. 4 and "Plato's
Metaphysical Epistemology" in The Cambridge Companion to Plato,
ed. Kraut.
-
Political Theory.
-
(A) Review Republic ii-ix, esp. 347bc, 368c 376d, 413c 434e, 451b
466d, 471c 474c, 487b 489d, 492a 496a, 499d 501c, 519b 521b, 539e 580c,
590a 592b.
-
(B) *Laws and *Statesman; Barker, The Political Thought
of Plato and Aristotle, esp. chs. 3-4; Brink, "Eudaimonism, Love and
Friendship, and Political Community"; *Mill, On Liberty; Popper,
The
Open Society and Its Enemies, vol. 1; Vlastos, "Was Plato a Feminist?";
White, "The Ruler's Choice".
9. PROBLEMS ABOUT FORMS: THE THIRD MAN AND THE PARMENIDES
-
(A) Parmenides, esp. through 137
-
(B) *Fine, "Aristotle and the More Accurate Arguments"; Cohen, "The Logic
of the Third Man"; Meinwald, "Good-bye to the Third Man" in The Cambridge
Companion to Plato, ed. Kraut; Rickless, "How Parmenides Saved the Forms";
*Vlastos, "Plato's Third Man Argument (Parm 132a1-b2)" in Vlastos, Platonic
Studies.